Generational Dynamics Forum - New Site

JDav wrote: ↑

Thu May 05, 2022 10:41 am

John, as I've been contemplating my posts the last couple of days, something came to me - is it possible that there is a spiritual component to Generational Theory? For instance, many have posited that the Catholic Church has gone through several great ages (about every 500 years), culminating in a church-wide crisis. The last one being, of course, the Reformation. And about 500 years before that, the schism with the Orthodox Christian Churches. Here we are, 500 years later, and the Church is roiled by decades of homosexuality & pedophilia, and all other manner of corruptions & immoralities that plague our society as a whole. I think, in some sense, that She is also in a Generational Crisis Era. I'm curious as to your thoughts on this?

Johnny bandwidth wrote: ↑

Thu May 05, 2022 11:49 am

JDav wrote: ↑

Thu May 05, 2022 10:23 am

Guest wrote: ↑

Thu May 05, 2022 7:30 am

You want everyone to suffer yours. I allow for choice. You do not. That is the difference.

Amen.

JCP

Don't know how you got "You want everyone to suffer yours" out of "You suffer yours, I'll suffer mine," but thanks for admitting that you are pro-death. The problem with your viewpoint is that, once you grant that one person has power over deciding the life/death of another, where does it stop? You will not be the final arbiter of who has power over who's life or death. Again, you illustrate the reasoning for my viewpoint perfectly. A viewpoint I've merely stated, by the way, not one that I've attempted to force you or anyone here to accept, though you seem to think otherwise.

'Nuf said...

To clarify, then you DO NOT want to legally ban abortion? It should be left up to the individual. Correct? Because otherwise, you would be FORCING your beliefs on others. Let's be crystal clear about what you are saying. You seem to be dancing around with this other poster. CLARIFY what you mean.

JDav wrote: ↑

Thu May 05, 2022 1:05 pm

Johnny bandwidth wrote: ↑

Thu May 05, 2022 11:49 am

JDav wrote: ↑

Thu May 05, 2022 10:23 am

Don't know how you got "You want everyone to suffer yours" out of "You suffer yours, I'll suffer mine," but thanks for admitting that you are pro-death. The problem with your viewpoint is that, once you grant that one person has power over deciding the life/death of another, where does it stop? You will not be the final arbiter of who has power over who's life or death. Again, you illustrate the reasoning for my viewpoint perfectly. A viewpoint I've merely stated, by the way, not one that I've attempted to force you or anyone here to accept, though you seem to think otherwise.

'Nuf said...

To clarify, then you DO NOT want to legally ban abortion? It should be left up to the individual. Correct? Because otherwise, you would be FORCING your beliefs on others. Let's be crystal clear about what you are saying. You seem to be dancing around with this other poster. CLARIFY what you mean.

Abortion has been around for millennia, practiced by many, if not all, societies throughout history. It is not an American creation. Legally banning it would not eliminate the practice. After defining what an abortion is I merely stated that I can't, and won't give my allegiance to a nation that condones this great evil (among other evils). Legality has nothing to do with it. Theology has little to do with it either. The belief that human life is special and sacred is not exclusive to religion.

We each have free will to make our own choices in life, but are not free of the consequences of those choices. On the face of it, the decision to abort or not (legally in this day and age; illegally in ages past) has clear and visible consequences. I believe (and have been told by many women I know who have had abortions) that there are spiritual and emotional consequences, too. As sentient, rational beings I don't see how there can't be. Whatever choices one makes in life will yield consequences with which one has to deal. You'll have to suffer yours as I'll have to suffer mine.

JDav wrote: ↑

Thu May 05, 2022 1:05 pm

Johnny bandwidth wrote: ↑

Thu May 05, 2022 11:49 am

JDav wrote: ↑

Thu May 05, 2022 10:23 am

Don't know how you got "You want everyone to suffer yours" out of "You suffer yours, I'll suffer mine," but thanks for admitting that you are pro-death. The problem with your viewpoint is that, once you grant that one person has power over deciding the life/death of another, where does it stop? You will not be the final arbiter of who has power over who's life or death. Again, you illustrate the reasoning for my viewpoint perfectly. A viewpoint I've merely stated, by the way, not one that I've attempted to force you or anyone here to accept, though you seem to think otherwise.

'Nuf said...

To clarify, then you DO NOT want to legally ban abortion? It should be left up to the individual. Correct? Because otherwise, you would be FORCING your beliefs on others. Let's be crystal clear about what you are saying. You seem to be dancing around with this other poster. CLARIFY what you mean.

Abortion has been around for millennia, practiced by many, if not all, societies throughout history. It is not an American creation. Legally banning it would not eliminate the practice. After defining what an abortion is I merely stated that I can't, and won't give my allegiance to a nation that condones this great evil (among other evils). Legality has nothing to do with it. Theology has little to do with it either. The belief that human life is special and sacred is not exclusive to religion.

We each have free will to make our own choices in life, but are not free of the consequences of those choices. On the face of it, the decision to abort or not (legally in this day and age; illegally in ages past) has clear and visible consequences. I believe (and have been told by many women I know who have had abortions) that there are spiritual and emotional consequences, too. As sentient, rational beings I don't see how there can't be. Whatever choices one makes in life will yield consequences with which one has to deal. You'll have to suffer yours as I'll have to suffer mine.

JDav wrote: ↑

Thu May 05, 2022 1:32 pm

JDav wrote: ↑

Thu May 05, 2022 1:05 pm

Johnny bandwidth wrote: ↑

Thu May 05, 2022 11:49 am

To clarify, then you DO NOT want to legally ban abortion? It should be left up to the individual. Correct? Because otherwise, you would be FORCING your beliefs on others. Let's be crystal clear about what you are saying. You seem to be dancing around with this other poster. CLARIFY what you mean.

Abortion has been around for millennia, practiced by many, if not all, societies throughout history. It is not an American creation. Legally banning it would not eliminate the practice. After defining what an abortion is I merely stated that I can't, and won't give my allegiance to a nation that condones this great evil (among other evils). Legality has nothing to do with it. Theology has little to do with it either. The belief that human life is special and sacred is not exclusive to religion.

We each have free will to make our own choices in life, but are not free of the consequences of those choices. On the face of it, the decision to abort or not (legally in this day and age; illegally in ages past) has clear and visible consequences. I believe (and have been told by many women I know who have had abortions) that there are spiritual and emotional consequences, too. As sentient, rational beings I don't see how there can't be. Whatever choices one makes in life will yield consequences with which one has to deal. You'll have to suffer yours as I'll have to suffer mine.

To be clear, the country is not morally ready for a legal ban on abortion, and I would not support one... for now. It would have little impact on all the choices that men and women make BEFORE the decision to abort or not is even necessary. But let me ask YOU for clarification - if killing someone is against the law, and abortion is the killing of an unborn child, shouldn't abortion be against the law?

JDav wrote: ↑

Thu May 05, 2022 1:34 pm

JDav wrote: ↑

Thu May 05, 2022 1:32 pm

JDav wrote: ↑

Thu May 05, 2022 1:05 pm

Abortion has been around for millennia, practiced by many, if not all, societies throughout history. It is not an American creation. Legally banning it would not eliminate the practice. After defining what an abortion is I merely stated that I can't, and won't give my allegiance to a nation that condones this great evil (among other evils). Legality has nothing to do with it. Theology has little to do with it either. The belief that human life is special and sacred is not exclusive to religion.

We each have free will to make our own choices in life, but are not free of the consequences of those choices. On the face of it, the decision to abort or not (legally in this day and age; illegally in ages past) has clear and visible consequences. I believe (and have been told by many women I know who have had abortions) that there are spiritual and emotional consequences, too. As sentient, rational beings I don't see how there can't be. Whatever choices one makes in life will yield consequences with which one has to deal. You'll have to suffer yours as I'll have to suffer mine.

To be clear, the country is not morally ready for a legal ban on abortion, and I would not support one... for now. It would have little impact on all the choices that men and women make BEFORE the decision to abort or not is even necessary. But let me ask YOU for clarification - if killing someone is against the law, and abortion is the killing of an unborn child, shouldn't abortion be against the law?

And, YOU don't dodge the question!