by John » Wed Jun 12, 2013 7:17 am
Well, you're right that the NSA program could be abused.
But let's put abuse aside for the moment, and ask if we need the IRS
and the NSA programs. Well, we all hate taxes but we still need the
IRS, and we all hate terrorists, so we still need the NSA.
Yes, the NSA program could be abused, but I would argue that that ship
has already sailed with the IRS. You have people in the IRS targeting
their political enemies and possibly their personal enemies as well,
with access to tax returns, bank data, credit card transactions, and
soon, doctors visits, prescriptions, medical copayments, and so forth.
So I would argue that once the abusers have all the IRS data, then
giving them my phone bill as well is not that big a deal. In other
words, we're not comparing the war against terror versus NSA abuse.
What we're comparing is the war against terror versus the INCREMENTAL
NSA abuse, given the abuse of the IRS data.
I guess I also believe that there are more protections in place for
the NSA data than for the IRS data. Snowden was an IT guy, and those
guys almost always have access to everything, which would not be true
of an ordinary employee.
Well, you're right that the NSA program could be abused.
But let's put abuse aside for the moment, and ask if we need the IRS
and the NSA programs. Well, we all hate taxes but we still need the
IRS, and we all hate terrorists, so we still need the NSA.
Yes, the NSA program could be abused, but I would argue that that ship
has already sailed with the IRS. You have people in the IRS targeting
their political enemies and possibly their personal enemies as well,
with access to tax returns, bank data, credit card transactions, and
soon, doctors visits, prescriptions, medical copayments, and so forth.
So I would argue that once the abusers have all the IRS data, then
giving them my phone bill as well is not that big a deal. In other
words, we're not comparing the war against terror versus NSA abuse.
What we're comparing is the war against terror versus the INCREMENTAL
NSA abuse, given the abuse of the IRS data.
I guess I also believe that there are more protections in place for
the NSA data than for the IRS data. Snowden was an IT guy, and those
guys almost always have access to everything, which would not be true
of an ordinary employee.