When you are trying to make up your mind about something, you have to go to the basics and work up from that, and by basics, I meant original data that's public and known to be good as you can get.
P1 - CO2-level changes in the air cause Air Temp Changes
P2 - Mankind's industry is causing CO2 level in air to increase
C1 - Mankind is causing the air temp to increase
So is P1 true?
Well... when in the past has P1 been true? Never! Never in the past has (have?) changes in CO2 levels in the air CAUSED the air temp to change. So why are they saying it's (the CO2 change) going to cause the air temp to change now?
P1A - Computer models
Well.. are those accurate? No they are not. Global Warming Alarmists are not able to predict anything with any accuracy
So I would say that P1 is so-far unsubstantiated and very close to being False.
It's up to the Global Warming Alarmists to establish P1. Until they do, they should be mocked and ridiculed.
Over millions of years worth of Antarctic ice core data there is a strong correlation between CO2 levels and Antarctic temperature. In statistics correlation is a requirement for causation, but does not prove causation.
xakzen wrote: CO2 is a green house gas, but not as strong a green house gas as H20 which is the dominate contributor to the life enabling green house effect on the planet.
xakzen wrote:The point is that in spite what either side is saying, the scientific question concerning the exact effect of burning large amounts of carbon based fuels is not known. It could be increasing the temperature and/or it could be inconsequential to the natural cyclical climate changes though which the Earth/Sun system go.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests