by batman » Sat Dec 12, 2009 6:01 pm
John, I have been following your blog for 4 or 5 years now. I agree with most of your points, but I have seen a few factual errors, especially when it comes to your understanding of the history of India, and the Kashmir issue. These are understandable, because you are not from the region and can't be expected to know its history as much as I do. I don't know the most intricate and esoteric details of the history of Ireland or Ukraine, for example. To improve your understanding, you may want to read "Our Oriental Heritage" by Will Durant. You will then understand better what Genocide really means, and how it feels to be a survivor of a 1000 year long Genocidal campaign.
Do not equate Hindus with Moslems in your Kashmir or India-Pakistan related articles. We (Hindus) have tolerated Genocidal pogroms for 1000 years in the hope that the bloodthirsty killers will become civilized after seeing how civilized people deal with them. In those 1000 years, the Buddhists of Central Asia and Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Bangladesh have been wiped out, as have Zoroastrians of Persia, and we Hindus in what remains of India have managed to survive only at massive cost of blood and tears, and that too, only because we were too large to get swallowed by the onslaught of Radical Islamic armies.
Americans and the West can choose to learn from the history of India and get a better understanding of what kind of an enemy they are dealing with. Osama bin Laden follows to the letter the very same book that was followed to the letter by Timurlane, Allauddin Khiljee, Nadir Shah, Muhammad Ghauri, Mahmood of Ghazni, Babur, Aurangzeb, and countless other mass killers who thought they were doing the work of God by killing hundreds of thousands of innocent and unarmed men women and children, and forcibly converting hundreds of thousands of young women through torture coercion and intimidation.
Obama seems to understand what evil means. If America and the West can learn from history, the chances will be lower that your grandchildren will learn those lessons of history through first-hand experience. If not, then History will repeat itself. It always does, until the lessons it seeks to teach are actually learned by its students. It is a teacher that cannot be escaped.
I agree with Obama that there exists pure evil in this world, and that the non-violent methods of Mahatma Gandhi and Martin Luther King (which worked against the civilized majorities in Great Britain and the United States) cannot work against certain kinds of adversaries.
However, all these years, in spite of seeing your factual errors when talking about the history of India, and the flaws in your understanding about the origins and reasons for the Hindu-Moslem conflicts, I have kept quiet because I really don't have the time or the inclination to waste my time writing messages (and especially responding to ignorant replies from anti-Hindu Moslems, or those sympathetic to their claims).
But after seeing this sentence from you in your currently most recent post, I had to respond:
Whether someone is "evil" depends on your political point of view.
You are wrong, John. Barack Obama is right. Pure evil does exist in this world. Everything is not relative. All of Morality is not relative. There are certain Moral Absolutes: Good, and Evil.
That is all I have to say. I will not respond to any replies to my post. I just do not have the time. Those Moslems or Moslem-appeasers who still deny the historical truths I alluded to (the genocide of between 80 million and 400 million Hindus over 1000 years by Radical Islamic killers subscribing to the very same "religious" ideology, and the very same textbook of mass-killing rape and pillage that Osama bin Laden swears by, in the Indian sub-continent -- described as the "bloodiest [genocide] in the history of Humanity" by Will Durant) can deny all they want. Just like they deny the Armenian Genocide perpetrated on Christians by people following the same ideology and the same textbook. Their denials may cloud the understanding of the ignorant masses living on Earth today (including many decision-makers in Senate and Congress, and in Government of many other countries), but in the long run that does not matter. The Laws of Karma are eternal, and the punishment for evil and Crimes Against Nature and Humanity cannot be prevented. Justice is built into the framework of the Universe, and though it may often seem delayed by our puny human timescales, it permits no cheating and no escape. Justice is always done. And Truth will always Triumph.
That is all.