25-Dec-17 World View -- Remembering the 1914 World War I Christmas Truce / The 'anti-war movement' in World War I

Post a reply


This question is a means of preventing automated form submissions by spambots.
Smilies
:D :) ;) :( :o :shock: :? 8-) :lol: :x :P :oops: :cry: :evil: :twisted: :roll: :!: :?: :idea: :arrow: :| :mrgreen: :geek: :ugeek:

BBCode is ON
[img] is ON
[flash] is OFF
[url] is ON
Smilies are ON

Topic review
   

Expand view Topic review: 25-Dec-17 World View -- Remembering the 1914 World War I Christmas Truce / The 'anti-war movement' in World War I

Re: 25-Dec-17 World View -- Remembering the 1914 World War I Christmas Truce / The 'anti-war movement' in World War I

by jmm1184 » Thu Jan 04, 2018 4:07 pm

I can only guess because I haven't researched it. Awakening climaxes
can occur late, so the fall of the Berlin wall is likely for
East Germany. For France, I would guess something to do with
de Gaulle. For the UK, maybe something to do with Thatcher,
although one would have to look at the four nations separately.
After doing a bit of reading, I've come to two candidates for United Kingdom: the resignation of Margaret Thatcher in 1990 after the poll tax riots, or the electoral landslide of New Labour under Blair in 1997, though I think that may be too late.

As for France, the May 1968 riots and the resignation of De Gaulle in 1969 read very well as a generational awakening climax, but they seem to be too early as the oldest post-war French person would only be 27 or 28 at oldest at De Gaulle's resignation.

Re: 25-Dec-17 World View -- Remembering the 1914 World War I Christmas Truce / The 'anti-war movement' in World War I

by John » Sun Dec 31, 2017 6:43 pm

jmm1184 wrote: > Speaking of awakening climaxes, do you have an idea of what
> happened in France or the UK as an awakening climax? I doubt they
> would have shared watergate as an awakening climax, but it doesn't
> make sense for the fall of the berlin wall to be it
> either.
I can only guess because I haven't researched it. Awakening climaxes
can occur late, so the fall of the Berlin wall is likely for
East Germany. For France, I would guess something to do with
de Gaulle. For the UK, maybe something to do with Thatcher,
although one would have to look at the four nations separately.

Re: 25-Dec-17 World View -- Remembering the 1914 World War I Christmas Truce / The 'anti-war movement' in World War I

by jmm1184 » Sat Dec 30, 2017 11:52 pm

World War II was an Awakening era war for Russia. Ten years ago,
David Kaiser opined that WW II was an Awakening war for Russia, but it
so thoroughly destroyed the Prophet generation that it postponed the
next crisis war, which hasn't yet occurred. This is similar to the
reasoning behind a "First Turning Reset," that occurs when a crisis
occurs during a non-crisis era. This could be an unexpected massive
invasion, or it could be a forced relocation of an entire population.
In either case, the population acts according to its era, but returns
to a First Turning Recovery Era following the crisis.
That makes sense. It also explains why both western and eastern europe experienced awakening climaxes at the same time even though their crisis wars occurred at different times.

Speaking of awakening climaxes, do you have an idea of what happened in France or the UK as an awakening climax? I doubt they would have shared watergate as an awakening climax, but it doesn't make sense for the fall of the berlin wall to be it either.

Re: 25-Dec-17 World View -- Remembering the 1914 World War I Christmas Truce / The 'anti-war movement' in World War I

by John » Sat Dec 30, 2017 10:21 am

jmm1184 wrote: > John, have you come across any anti-war or anti-establishment
> activities in E. Europe during WWII?

> I remember on a thread earlier from a few months back one of the
> users suspecting Russia actually went through a first-turning
> reset, and I'm increasingly thinking this to be the case. I also
> suspect this is the case for E Europe, except strangely enough for
> the Balkans - perhaps because the Nazis were not as harsh
> there?
You can't really have an anti-war movement when your country is
being invaded by the Nazis.

I did once post a story about Uzbekistan staying out of WW II and
carrying out a "humanitarian mission" by sheltering refugees.

** Islamist Uzbeks lead terrorists in Pakistan and Afghanistan
** http://www.generationaldynamics.com/pg/ ... tm#e091102


One of the most amazing stories occurred during Napoleon's invasion
of Russia, when the Russian people deserted Moscow.

** Book I / Chapter 5 -- Leo Tolstoy's War and Peace
** http://www.generationaldynamics.com/pg/ ... olstoy.htm

World War II was an Awakening era war for Russia. Ten years ago,
David Kaiser opined that WW II was an Awakening war for Russia, but it
so thoroughly destroyed the Prophet generation that it postponed the
next crisis war, which hasn't yet occurred. This is similar to the
reasoning behind a "First Turning Reset," that occurs when a crisis
occurs during a non-crisis era. This could be an unexpected massive
invasion, or it could be a forced relocation of an entire population.
In either case, the population acts according to its era, but returns
to a First Turning Recovery Era following the crisis.

Re: 25-Dec-17 World View -- Remembering the 1914 World War I Christmas Truce / The 'anti-war movement' in World War I

by Trevor » Sat Dec 30, 2017 9:01 am

World War I is also a reason why, at least from my observations, that people have trouble with Generational Dynamics and The Fourth Turning theory. I've frequently heard: "You're ignoring WWI to make the cycle work."

Another parallel with Vietnam is also how returning veterans were frequently treated. In the United States, the Bonus Army was crushed and dispersed. In both America and Europe, veterans returning home did not receive praise, parades, or frequently, any kind of recognition at all.

Germany certainly deserves a share of the blame, but unlike the second, there was plenty of blame to go around. France both wanted revenge and feared having to face Germany alone, Austria-Hungary wanted an excuse to crush Serbia, Russia wanted to protect and influence its fellow slavs, and so on.

Erich Remarque also wrote a sequel (kind of) called: "The Road Back". One of the thing it mentioned was that while older people could go back to their lives, the younger soldiers knew nothing else besides the war.

Re: 25-Dec-17 World View -- Remembering the 1914 World War I Christmas Truce / The 'anti-war movement' in World War I

by jmm1184 » Fri Dec 29, 2017 10:56 pm

Yeah, they were called communist revolutions.
Explain? Especially since most of them were instigated by Russia after liberation.
Were there antiwar movements in E Europe, the Balkans, Russia, or the Middle East during WWII?
The 'anti-war movement' in World War I
John, have you come across any anti-war or anti-establishment activities in E. Europe during WWII?

I remember on a thread earlier from a few months back one of the users suspecting Russia actually went through a first-turning reset, and I'm increasingly thinking this to be the case. I also suspect this is the case for E Europe, except strangely enough for the Balkans - perhaps because the Nazis were not as harsh there?

Re: 25-Dec-17 World View -- Remembering the 1914 World War I Christmas Truce / The 'anti-war movement' in World War I

by FishbellykanakaDude » Fri Dec 29, 2017 2:14 pm

Captain Obvious wrote:After a nuclear war, will anyone bother with writing history books?
Yes. Obviously.

..but those histories will all be "local", and rather "mythological epic", in nature.

Re: 25-Dec-17 World View -- Remembering the 1914 World War I Christmas Truce / The 'anti-war movement' in World War I

by Captain Obvious » Fri Dec 29, 2017 3:52 am

After a nuclear war, will anyone bother with writing history books?

Re: 25-Dec-17 World View -- Remembering the 1914 World War I Christmas Truce / The 'anti-war movement' in World War I

by uncertainty » Fri Dec 29, 2017 3:34 am

John wrote:
uncertainty wrote: > What you can't not love about this forum is the
> consistency. "Merry Christmas don't forget WWIII could be this
> coming year...."
I would say this the other way around. It's the thousands of
mainstream media sources that are all consistent with one another.
This forum is the only one that's inconsistent with them.
uncertainty wrote: > At this point I'm so interested to see what the post war era looks
> like. I wonder if the underlying anxiety goes away at that point
> or if it is just seared into the fiber of your being.
If that question really interests you, then do some research
on news, movies and literature immediately after World War II.

On a number of occasions, I've quoted what Hannah Arendt wrote in her
1950 book, <i>The Origins of Totalitarianism</i>:
Thanks John will do! One thing I have noticed is it seems when people talk about "the world" at the beginning of a new shift it actually describes the mood of the previous era pretty well. Am I bonkers or have you seen this too?

Re: 25-Dec-17 World View -- Remembering the 1914 World War I Christmas Truce / The 'anti-war movement' in World War I

by FishbellykanakaDude » Thu Dec 28, 2017 3:50 am

John wrote:...
On a number of occasions, I've quoted what Hannah Arendt wrote in her
1950 book, <i>The Origins of Totalitarianism</i>:
Hannah Arendt in 1950 wrote: > ................................................we watch the development
> of the same phenomena -- homelessness on an unprecedented scale,
> rootlessness to an unprecedented depth.

> .....................It is as though mankind had divided itself between
> those who believe in human omnipotence (who think that everything
> is possible if one knows how to organize masses for it) and those
> for whom powerlessness has become the major experience of their
> lives."
Utopians with ANY amount of power produce despair in "the masses".

Despair is hopelessness, which allows powerlessness.

THIS is why SJWs, "Sisyphus Ratchetus"-type so-called Progressives, and politicians who claim the ability to "fix things" are to be laughed at and denied dinner and lodging at all Howard Johnson's world wide.

The Utopians will be eaten by their enemies AND their former followers, when the worm turns,.. when the youth flip.

When will the youth flip? Watch for the youth to flip. When the youth flip, you've got one summer, one winter, and one spring until the "Feast on the Utopians" gets seated for the meal.


Aloha. <shaka!>

Top